So what did I throw away?

Evan, complaining about his back hurting grinned and asked me if I had any codeine.

I told him that I did but that we had thrown it all away after he revealed his addiction.

"No you didn't."

"Yeah. I did. I was there. We got the bottles out of the lock box and we flushed the pills."

"None of it was codeine."

"You mean you took it and replaced the pills?"

"I'm not stupid!"