Friday, September 12, 2008

Palin Interview

What Fallows said.

I know I said I would back off of political blogging, but I want to say this, and I know there are at least some Palin-fans who agree with what I am going to say, although they wouldn't use my example.

I lived in Indiana when Dan Quayle was senator. I wrote to him periodically arguing against his positions. Though the letters I got back from other politicians were generally meaningless and non-commital ("thank you for your letter. It is important to me to hear from you."), his were thoughtful. I read them and thought, "Okay, I don't agree with this guy, but he is smart and he is fair."

Then he was picked to be Vice President and transformed into someone I did not know. Dan Quayle's new job assignment seemed to be: go keep the religious right happy.

He sucked at it.

He had the potential to have one day been an influencial and important person to the Republican Party. He was young, bright, capable, but was put in a role for which he was not suited.

Years later I saw an interview in which he was running for something and he told the interviewer that most of America did not know the real Dan Quayle and they were going to be surprised about who he really was. And I thought, "He's right, but he is never going to get anyone to listen."

A young, smart, thoughtful, fair guy with whom I disagreed but respected had been made the punch-line of a joke. It wasn't fair to him.

And something similar is happening to Palin. If her job is just to keep the religious right happy, then she can probably do that well. However, her job is to do more than that, and she just isn't ready. She just isn't. It isn't a personality attack. She just doesn't know the stuff she needs to know to be ready to take over for a guy who is getting up there.

And it isn't fair to her.

Or to us.


  1. I was embarrassed for her and I'm wondering how she felt after that interview. If she loves the country as she says she does, she should step down and let someone more prepared step in.

  2. From a Mother's view point, I just can't believe that she accepted the nomination knowing full well it would bring her daughter under the microscope. Being a teenager is tough enough, being a pregnant, unwed teenager under intense scrutiny? How does she get through that? Inexcusable in my eyes! Why would you do that to your daughter?

  3. So true. The sad thing about this, from Palin's point of view, is that 8 years from now she might well have been a terrific candidate. She'd still be plenty young, her kids would be older, and she'd have had a chance to learn more about governing and about all the relevant issues. She's bright, eloquent, and there's a reason she's been seen as a rising star. Being chosen too soon could well end up destroying a promising career.

  4. To Dawn's point, I don't think she has the humility to be embarrassed. That lack of humility makes me suspect even the most promising. I doubt I could ever look at her seriously again.

  5. I do wonder whatever possessed her to accept.

  6. Oh you put this so succinctly! I wish I could do this with all the right wingers where i work!


Comments will be open for a little while, then I will be shutting them off. The blog will stay, but I do not want either to moderate comments or leave the blog available to spammers.